The Soccer Championship Game
My 10-year-old daughter, Grace, played soccer this fall for the first time. I signed her up for it through the town’s recreation program. My older daughter played for years through that program and she’d always enjoyed it. Kind of low key, only one practice a week, and inexpensive. A good way to sample a sport. Parents get to root for their child while mingling with neighbors and friends from the community.
Grace was randomly placed on a team. Two coaches. One quiet and one…not so quiet. Truthfully, quite obnoxiously loud. He’d actually run up and down the sidelines as the little girls played, barking out, “Get the ball, Go, Go, GO, Stay with it, be more aggressive, where’s my defense…” You get the idea.
But he’d also send these very encouraging e-mails to the girls and there is no doubt that Grace learned a ton. Naturally, she’s not as skilled as some of the girls who had been playing for years. But she has some natural athletic ability and a fierce heart. She likes to win. She really likes to win.
So, I kind of sat back and tried not to judge. Grace was enjoying the experience tremendously. Plus, neither my husband nor I have any desire to coach so my feeling is that you can’t really criticize unless you’re willing to do the job yourself.
Well, her team made it to the championship game. It was almost a joke because the girls would almost accidentally make a goal or kick the ball in the right direction. But, regardless, the team was extremely excited. On the morning of the big game, Grace woke up at 7:30 a.m. to kick the ball around outside in the freezing rain, just to get ready. The whole family went to the game. This was a big deal. We went loaded down with chairs, blankets, snacks, and of course our camcorder and camera in order to have pictures to mark the big event and to share with family through Photoworks. We were pumped!
Well, the coach hardly played Grace. He put her in for less than one quarter and some girls played the entire game. It wasn’t even kind of close.
I have a friend who is a wonderful coach and he has to actually keep a spreadsheet because parents question if their child is getting equal field time. I’m so not that parent. I’m sure it’s nearly impossible to keep it even. We’d settle for anything remotely resembling even. The thing is, Gracie’s coaches had been very fair for the entire season. So, this was obviously all about winning the “big game.” And Grace figured that out and all it implied. I could see it in her face.
So, I was absolutely thrilled when Gracie’s team lost. So much for his strategy. Hah! Yes, I am petty. Grace walked toward me and I could tell even from a distance that she was struggling to hold it together. We all know that feeling that you get when you see your Mom where your throat closes up and your chest gets tight. It still happens to me when something is wrong in my life, even as an adult.
Grace laid her head on me and whispered, “Why didn’t he play me?”
What is the correct response to that? I didn’t answer but just hugged her. As parents, we work so hard to build our children’s confidence and self-esteem and it can all fall apart so quickly.
The quieter coach came over, apologized, and told Grace that he hoped to see her on the team for spring soccer. I kept my mouth closed. Honestly, I just didn’t know what to say.
To be fair, both coaches were always upbeat with Grace, enthusiastic, and volunteered lots of their time. So, I’m really trying to figure this out. Is this just the way of sports and Grace needs to get used to it? Or have kids’ sports become hyper-competitive at all levels? When spring comes around, do I sign her up for the same team?
Dr. Alan Goldberg wrote a great article regarding youth sports entitled “13 Steps to Winning Parenting” that has one step called “giving your child the gift of failure.” It’s difficult to sort it all out and to determine what is best for my child.
-Kay